Better Format Sorting (Squashed)

* Added --format-sort (-S height,filesize)
* Made fields reversible (-S +height)
* Added --format-sort-force, --no-format-sort-force
* Added limit (-S height:720)
* Added codec preference (-S vcodec,acodec)
* Correct handling of preference<-1000

* Rebased to yt-dlc
* Automatically determine missing bitrates
* aext, vext, protocol, acodec, vcodec can now takes priority as string, not number (-S vext:webm)
* Correct handling of None in codec, audio_codec (None means the codec is unknown while 'none' means it doesn't exist)
* Correctly parse filesize (-S filesize:200M)
* Generalized preference calculation

* Rewrote entire code into the class FormatSort
* Correctly handle user input errors
* Combined fields (-S +ext:webm:webm)
* Closest mode (-S filesize~50M)
* Aliases (framerate=fps, br=bitrate etc)

* Documentation
This commit is contained in:
pukkandan
2020-10-26 21:20:09 +05:30
parent 98e248faa4
commit eb8a44336c
6 changed files with 448 additions and 103 deletions

View File

@@ -32,6 +32,7 @@ from ..compat import (
compat_urlparse,
compat_xml_parse_error,
)
from ..downloader import FileDownloader
from ..downloader.f4m import (
get_base_url,
remove_encrypted_media,
@@ -1354,81 +1355,270 @@ class InfoExtractor(object):
html, '%s form' % form_id, group='form')
return self._hidden_inputs(form)
def _sort_formats(self, formats, field_preference=None):
class FormatSort:
regex = r' *((?P<reverse>\+)?(?P<field>[a-zA-Z0-9_]+)((?P<seperator>[~:])(?P<limit>.*?))?)? *$'
default = ('hidden', 'has_video', 'has_audio', 'extractor', 'lang', 'quality',
'tbr', 'filesize', 'vbr', 'height', 'width', 'protocol', 'vext',
'abr', 'aext', 'fps', 'filesize_approx', 'source_preference', 'format_id')
settings = {
'vcodec': {'type': 'ordered', 'regex': True,
'order': ['av01', 'vp9', '(h265|he?vc?)', '(h264|avc)', 'vp8', '(mp4v|h263)', 'theora', '', None, 'none']},
'acodec': {'type': 'ordered', 'regex': True,
'order': ['opus', 'vorbis', 'aac', 'mp?4a?', 'mp3', 'e?a?c-?3', 'dts', '', None, 'none']},
'protocol': {'type': 'ordered', 'regex': True,
'order': ['(ht|f)tps', '(ht|f)tp$', 'm3u8.+', 'm3u8', '.*dash', '', 'mms|rtsp', 'none', 'f4']},
'vext': {'type': 'ordered', 'field': 'video_ext',
'order': ('mp4', 'flv', 'webm', '', 'none'), # Why is flv prefered over webm???
'order_free': ('webm', 'mp4', 'flv', '', 'none')},
'aext': {'type': 'ordered', 'field': 'audio_ext',
'order': ('m4a', 'aac', 'mp3', 'ogg', 'opus', 'webm', '', 'none'),
'order_free': ('opus', 'ogg', 'webm', 'm4a', 'mp3', 'aac', '', 'none')},
'hidden': {'visible': False, 'forced': True, 'type': 'extractor', 'max': -1000},
'extractor_preference': {'priority': True, 'type': 'extractor'},
'has_video': {'priority': True, 'field': 'vcodec', 'type': 'boolean', 'not_in_list': ('none',)},
'has_audio': {'priority': True, 'field': 'acodec', 'type': 'boolean', 'not_in_list': ('none',)},
'language_preference': {'priority': True, 'convert': 'ignore'},
'quality': {'priority': True, 'convert': 'float_none'},
'filesize': {'convert': 'bytes'},
'filesize_approx': {'convert': 'bytes'},
'format_id': {'convert': 'string'},
'height': {'convert': 'float_none'},
'width': {'convert': 'float_none'},
'fps': {'convert': 'float_none'},
'tbr': {'convert': 'float_none'},
'vbr': {'convert': 'float_none'},
'abr': {'convert': 'float_none'},
'asr': {'convert': 'float_none'},
'source_preference': {'convert': 'ignore'},
'codec': {'type': 'combined', 'field': ('vcodec', 'acodec')},
'bitrate': {'type': 'combined', 'field': ('tbr', 'vbr', 'abr'), 'same_limit': True},
'filesize_estimate': {'type': 'combined', 'same_limit': True, 'field': ('filesize', 'filesize_approx')},
'extension': {'type': 'combined', 'field': ('vext', 'aext')},
'dimension': {'type': 'multiple', 'field': ('height', 'width'), 'function': min}, # not named as 'resolution' because such a field exists
'res': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'dimension'},
'ext': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'extension'},
'br': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'bitrate'},
'total_bitrate': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'tbr'},
'video_bitrate': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'vbr'},
'audio_bitrate': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'abr'},
'framerate': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'fps'},
'lang': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'language_preference'}, # not named as 'language' because such a field exists
'proto': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'protocol'},
'source': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'source_preference'},
'size': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'filesize_estimate'},
'samplerate': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'asr'},
'video_ext': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'vext'},
'audio_ext': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'aext'},
'video_codec': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'vcodec'},
'audio_codec': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'acodec'},
'video': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'has_video'},
'audio': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'has_audio'},
'extractor': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'extractor_preference'},
'preference': {'type': 'alias', 'field': 'extractor_preference'}}
_order = []
def _get_field_setting(self, field, key):
if field not in self.settings:
self.settings[field] = {}
propObj = self.settings[field]
if key not in propObj:
type = propObj.get('type')
if key == 'field':
default = 'preference' if type == 'extractor' else (field,) if type in ('combined', 'multiple') else field
elif key == 'convert':
default = 'order' if type == 'ordered' else 'float_string' if field else 'ignore'
else:
default = {'type': 'field', 'visible': True, 'order': [], 'not_in_list': (None,), 'function': max}.get(key, None)
propObj[key] = default
return propObj[key]
def _resolve_field_value(self, field, value, convertNone=False):
if value is None:
if not convertNone:
return None
else:
value = value.lower()
conversion = self._get_field_setting(field, 'convert')
if conversion == 'ignore':
return None
if conversion == 'string':
return value
elif conversion == 'float_none':
return float_or_none(value)
elif conversion == 'bytes':
return FileDownloader.parse_bytes(value)
elif conversion == 'order':
order_free = self._get_field_setting(field, 'order_free')
order_list = order_free if order_free and self._use_free_order else self._get_field_setting(field, 'order')
use_regex = self._get_field_setting(field, 'regex')
list_length = len(order_list)
empty_pos = order_list.index('') if '' in order_list else list_length + 1
if use_regex and value is not None:
for (i, regex) in enumerate(order_list):
if regex and re.match(regex, value):
return list_length - i
return list_length - empty_pos # not in list
else: # not regex or value = None
return list_length - (order_list.index(value) if value in order_list else empty_pos)
else:
if value.isnumeric():
return float(value)
else:
self.settings[field]['convert'] = 'string'
return value
def evaluate_params(self, params, sort_extractor):
self._use_free_order = params.get('prefer_free_formats', False)
self._sort_user = params.get('format_sort', [])
self._sort_extractor = sort_extractor
def add_item(field, reverse, closest, limit_text):
field = field.lower()
if field in self._order:
return
self._order.append(field)
limit = self._resolve_field_value(field, limit_text)
data = {
'reverse': reverse,
'closest': False if limit is None else closest,
'limit_text': limit_text,
'limit': limit}
if field in self.settings:
self.settings[field].update(data)
else:
self.settings[field] = data
sort_list = (
tuple(field for field in self.default if self._get_field_setting(field, 'forced'))
+ (tuple() if params.get('format_sort_force', False)
else tuple(field for field in self.default if self._get_field_setting(field, 'priority')))
+ tuple(self._sort_user) + tuple(sort_extractor) + self.default)
for item in sort_list:
match = re.match(self.regex, item)
if match is None:
raise ExtractorError('Invalid format sort string "%s" given by extractor' % item)
field = match.group('field')
if field is None:
continue
if self._get_field_setting(field, 'type') == 'alias':
field = self._get_field_setting(field, 'field')
reverse = match.group('reverse') is not None
closest = match.group('seperator') == '~'
limit_text = match.group('limit')
has_limit = limit_text is not None
has_multiple_fields = self._get_field_setting(field, 'type') == 'combined'
has_multiple_limits = has_limit and has_multiple_fields and not self._get_field_setting(field, 'same_limit')
fields = self._get_field_setting(field, 'field') if has_multiple_fields else (field,)
limits = limit_text.split(":") if has_multiple_limits else (limit_text,) if has_limit else tuple()
limit_count = len(limits)
for (i, f) in enumerate(fields):
add_item(f, reverse, closest,
limits[i] if i < limit_count
else limits[0] if has_limit and not has_multiple_limits
else None)
def print_verbose_info(self, to_screen):
to_screen('[debug] Sort order given by user: %s' % ','.join(self._sort_user))
if self._sort_extractor:
to_screen('[debug] Sort order given by extractor: %s' % ','.join(self._sort_extractor))
to_screen('[debug] Formats sorted by: %s' % ', '.join(['%s%s%s' % (
'+' if self._get_field_setting(field, 'reverse') else '', field,
'%s%s(%s)' % ('~' if self._get_field_setting(field, 'closest') else ':',
self._get_field_setting(field, 'limit_text'),
self._get_field_setting(field, 'limit'))
if self._get_field_setting(field, 'limit_text') is not None else '')
for field in self._order if self._get_field_setting(field, 'visible')]))
def _calculate_field_preference_from_value(self, format, field, type, value):
reverse = self._get_field_setting(field, 'reverse')
closest = self._get_field_setting(field, 'closest')
limit = self._get_field_setting(field, 'limit')
if type == 'extractor':
maximum = self._get_field_setting(field, 'max')
if value is None or (maximum is not None and value >= maximum):
value = 0
elif type == 'boolean':
in_list = self._get_field_setting(field, 'in_list')
not_in_list = self._get_field_setting(field, 'not_in_list')
value = 0 if ((in_list is None or value in in_list) and (not_in_list is None or value not in not_in_list)) else -1
elif type == 'ordered':
value = self._resolve_field_value(field, value, True)
# try to convert to number
val_num = float_or_none(value)
is_num = self._get_field_setting(field, 'convert') != 'string' and val_num is not None
if is_num:
value = val_num
return ((-10, 0) if value is None
else (1, value, 0) if not is_num # if a field has mixed strings and numbers, strings are sorted higher
else (0, -abs(value - limit), value - limit if reverse else limit - value) if closest
else (0, value, 0) if not reverse and (limit is None or value <= limit)
else (0, -value, 0) if limit is None or (reverse and value == limit) or value > limit
else (-1, value, 0))
def _calculate_field_preference(self, format, field):
type = self._get_field_setting(field, 'type') # extractor, boolean, ordered, field, multiple
get_value = lambda f: format.get(self._get_field_setting(f, 'field'))
if type == 'multiple':
type = 'field' # Only 'field' is allowed in multiple for now
actual_fields = self._get_field_setting(field, 'field')
def wrapped_function(values):
values = tuple(filter(lambda x: x is not None, values))
return (self._get_field_setting(field, 'function')(*values) if len(values) > 1
else values[0] if values
else None)
value = wrapped_function((get_value(f) for f in actual_fields))
else:
value = get_value(field)
return self._calculate_field_preference_from_value(format, field, type, value)
def calculate_preference(self, format):
# Determine missing protocol
if not format.get('protocol'):
format['protocol'] = determine_protocol(format)
# Determine missing ext
if not format.get('ext') and 'url' in format:
format['ext'] = determine_ext(format['url'])
if format.get('vcodec') == 'none':
format['audio_ext'] = format['ext']
format['video_ext'] = 'none'
else:
format['video_ext'] = format['ext']
format['audio_ext'] = 'none'
# if format.get('preference') is None and format.get('ext') in ('f4f', 'f4m'): # Not supported?
# format['preference'] = -1000
# Determine missing bitrates
if format.get('tbr') is None:
if format.get('vbr') is not None and format.get('abr') is not None:
format['tbr'] = format.get('vbr', 0) + format.get('abr', 0)
else:
if format.get('vcodec') != "none" and format.get('vbr') is None:
format['vbr'] = format.get('tbr') - format.get('abr', 0)
if format.get('acodec') != "none" and format.get('abr') is None:
format['abr'] = format.get('tbr') - format.get('vbr', 0)
return tuple(self._calculate_field_preference(format, field) for field in self._order)
def _sort_formats(self, formats, field_preference=[]):
if not formats:
raise ExtractorError('No video formats found')
for f in formats:
# Automatically determine tbr when missing based on abr and vbr (improves
# formats sorting in some cases)
if 'tbr' not in f and f.get('abr') is not None and f.get('vbr') is not None:
f['tbr'] = f['abr'] + f['vbr']
def _formats_key(f):
# TODO remove the following workaround
from ..utils import determine_ext
if not f.get('ext') and 'url' in f:
f['ext'] = determine_ext(f['url'])
if isinstance(field_preference, (list, tuple)):
return tuple(
f.get(field)
if f.get(field) is not None
else ('' if field == 'format_id' else -1)
for field in field_preference)
preference = f.get('preference')
if preference is None:
preference = 0
if f.get('ext') in ['f4f', 'f4m']: # Not yet supported
preference -= 0.5
protocol = f.get('protocol') or determine_protocol(f)
proto_preference = 0 if protocol in ['http', 'https'] else (-0.5 if protocol == 'rtsp' else -0.1)
if f.get('vcodec') == 'none': # audio only
preference -= 50
if self._downloader.params.get('prefer_free_formats'):
ORDER = ['aac', 'mp3', 'm4a', 'webm', 'ogg', 'opus']
else:
ORDER = ['webm', 'opus', 'ogg', 'mp3', 'aac', 'm4a']
ext_preference = 0
try:
audio_ext_preference = ORDER.index(f['ext'])
except ValueError:
audio_ext_preference = -1
else:
if f.get('acodec') == 'none': # video only
preference -= 40
if self._downloader.params.get('prefer_free_formats'):
ORDER = ['flv', 'mp4', 'webm']
else:
ORDER = ['webm', 'flv', 'mp4']
try:
ext_preference = ORDER.index(f['ext'])
except ValueError:
ext_preference = -1
audio_ext_preference = 0
return (
preference,
f.get('language_preference') if f.get('language_preference') is not None else -1,
f.get('quality') if f.get('quality') is not None else -1,
f.get('tbr') if f.get('tbr') is not None else -1,
f.get('filesize') if f.get('filesize') is not None else -1,
f.get('vbr') if f.get('vbr') is not None else -1,
f.get('height') if f.get('height') is not None else -1,
f.get('width') if f.get('width') is not None else -1,
proto_preference,
ext_preference,
f.get('abr') if f.get('abr') is not None else -1,
audio_ext_preference,
f.get('fps') if f.get('fps') is not None else -1,
f.get('filesize_approx') if f.get('filesize_approx') is not None else -1,
f.get('source_preference') if f.get('source_preference') is not None else -1,
f.get('format_id') if f.get('format_id') is not None else '',
)
formats.sort(key=_formats_key)
format_sort = self.FormatSort() # params and to_screen are taken from the downloader
format_sort.evaluate_params(self._downloader.params, field_preference)
if self._downloader.params.get('verbose', False):
format_sort.print_verbose_info(self._downloader.to_screen)
formats.sort(key=lambda f: format_sort.calculate_preference(f))
def _check_formats(self, formats, video_id):
if formats: